New York’s MTA is claiming that they own the copyright over their schedule and are attempting to block an iphone application that shows their schedules. The blog, StationStops, is now in a fight with the MTA over the use of the iphone app.
While the MTA dropped the lawsuit against the website, they are pressing forward with one against the iphone. They are also making some large demands from StationStops.
Earlier this month, MTA marketers and then lawyers contacted him to demand he sign a license agreement or take down his iPhone app. At one point, the lawyers also claimed that his site appeared to be an official MTA site. Perhaps realizing the enormous fallout that would come from headlines like “MTA tries to silence blogger critical of its operations,” they quickly backed off that particular claim. However, they continued to demand a share of his revenue, retroactive payment for prior sales, and a $5,000 license fee on top.
The problem is that this really isn’t a copyright issue. Copyright is limited to artistic works. An MTA schedule is not artistic. You can’t copyright facts, which is what the MTA schedule is.


